Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eye Shadow
I really liked the balance of shimmery and matte hues in the Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eye Shadow Review ($50), which meant I only needed one palette to create a finished eye look. The formula was also just as creamy and easy to blend as the original.
While I think these shadows aren't quite as pigmented as the OG, they are extremely buildable, allowing you to easily control how much color you apply to your eyes. This formula, combined with the wearable array of colors inside, makes this product ideal for those who prefer to stick to neutrals. Most of the colors in the palette are work and school appropriate, but it still has enough wildcard shades (like the mustard yellow, Butterscotch) to keep things interesting and allow you to experiment.