Step 2: Eyes
The key in recreating Lady Gaga's "metalhead" look is in the Haus Laboratories Glam Attack Liquid Shimmer Powder in Biker ($20 for one; $36 for the duo). "You want to make sure you shake it before you use it because it's full of pigment and pearl," said Tanno. "For her, this felt like something you can take from the groupie to the rockstar — all in the way you build the makeup."
She applied the smoky color straight from the tube, which slipped across my lids like melted charcoal. "The doe-foot applicator makes it easy to use, and the formula itself goes on like a liquid but dries like a powder," Tanno said.